A brief Jack query
Tuesday, February 26th, 2008 by ptmSo watching the Oscars the other night reminded me of two things. One, I need to finish my 2007 In Music posts so I can get out my 2007 in Movies posts. I probably won’t be done with reviewing 2007 until March 2008 begins. Uncalled for.
Two, something that’s been bothering me for a while. They did a little montage…well, many little montages, actually, but this one in particular. It was a montage of all the Best Picture winners. It ended, of course, with 2006’s The Departed. Which was a phenomenal movie, and is I assume generally considered to be pretty great.
But I’ve heard some chatter, mainly from The Sports Guy, that Nicholson’s performance in that movie is considered awful. There’s never really any further exposition about why it’s awful…just that he did a horrible job and brings down the whole movie.
Uhhhh…what? Really? I’ve seen the movie a handful of times, even once with this vague criticism fresh in my mind. And, frankly, I don’t get it. I’m not saying it’s the best performance he’s ever turned in. I’m not saying his Boston accent isn’t hellishly forced from time to time. And I’m not saying that it’s everything you possibly could have dreamed it might be when you heard that Scorcese was finally directing Jack. But…it’s a perfectly credible performance, with some great moments. He very rarely ends up looking like the over-the-top maniacal caricature of himself that he can sometimes resort to…and when he does (most obviously when he makes the rat face in the closed restaurant when questioning DiCaprio), it makes sense in the context of the movie as Costello is totally falling apart.
So I turn it over to you, dear readers: what gives? Where’s the negative energy? Is it people pissed that Jack wouldn’t wear a Sox hat in the movie because he loves the Yankees so much? Is it Simmons-heads dittoing away at whatever the BSG tells them? Is it just that some people are sick of Nich…olson? Teach me, people. Teach me.
